Coffee heat rising

Siri, Drive Me to Independence, Please

And I don’t mean Missouri. 🙂  Here’s a recent update on a very interesting technological development, the self-drive, self-park private vehicle.

This thing, if it ever comes to fruition, could present a partial solution to the huge headache America faces as its baby-boom generation ages away from independence. The biggest pressure to move oneself into a life-care or assisted care institution is loss of the ability to drive a car. And the reason for that is that in about 99.9% of American towns and cities, public transit is simply not a practical option.

Most of us wish not to be warehoused in a holding pen where old folks wait for death. It’s a horrible prospect, and those of us who know people who have enjoyed that treatment have seen the depression and decline that quickly follow admission to one of those places, which drain your life savings in exchange for sad living conditions and bad food. But for many of us, there’s really no other choice.

If you don’t live in a city like New York, which has more or less usable public transit, your days of living independently in your own home expire with your final driver’s license. A friend of mine, Tootsie, saw exactly that happen to her.

In her mid-80s, she ran a signal at a major intersection and, not surprisingly, someone crashed into her. No one was injured, thank goodness, but both cars were totaled. A few months later, she ran a stop sign in my neighborhood, apparently because she thought it was a four-way stop. It was not. The SUV that ran into her was, yes, totaled. Again, no one was hurt.

But the two accidents in close succession alarmed her kids so much that they insisted she get rid of the car, which, being the accommodating type, she did.

The result was dismal.

She lived just far enough away from her son that it was inconvenient for him to get to her place to help her and drive her around on errands — nor did he feel much enthusiasm for having to do so. He would go out there about once every week or ten days. Less, if he could get away with it.

Phoenix being a 100% automobile-oriented city, access to even the most basic necessities meant blocks of walking through heat that can reach 118 degrees in the shade. Heat radiating off asphalt and concrete can make your external car thermometer register numbers upwards of 125 degrees.

Public transit in Tootsie’s part of town was essentially nonexistent. She tried: waited 30 minutes before a bus showed up. I myself have stood for 45 minutes waiting for a bus in this town. Few bus stops here provide seating or shade structures — most people end up standing in the full sun or, if a nearby business or home has a lawn, sitting on the grass. Getting around on public transport here is extremely inconvenient for younger, fit people and out of the question for the elderly.

The city used to have a Dial-a-Ride service for the disabled and the elderly, but recently they discontinued access to it for people who were merely too old to walk far. Unless you’re in a wheelchair or on crutches, you can’t use that anymore.

This meant she couldn’t get groceries, she couldn’t buy personal products or pick up a prescription, she couldn’t take her ailing dog to the vet, she couldn’t get herself to the doctor unless her son or a friend drove to her home, picked her up, and schlepped her around town.

Trapped in her double-wide, she grew increasingly depressed and listless. When her daughter visited from Seattle, she was appalled to find the cupboards low on food and Tootsie’s normally spotless house disheveled. She persuaded her brother that their mother should be put in a care home, and within a few weeks, off she went to the Beatitudes.

This old-folk’s warren is one of the better institutes in town. But still…an institution is what it is.

Tootsie, who had a resilient and up-beat personality, at first bubbled on cheerfully about how grand it was to have someone else to do the cleaning and cooking. But it didn’t take long for the depressing aspects of imprisonment in a one-room studio inside a facility with locks on the doors to take effect. Within a few months, she lost interest in living, withered away, and died.

Personally, I’d rather take a flying leap off the North Rim of the Grand Canyon than die a day at a time in an “assisted living facility.” I am convinced that Tootsie would have lived longer if she had been able to stay in her home, and the quality of the last year or two of her life would have been infinitely better.

Being able to get to grocery stores, drug stores, and other routine destinations on her own would have made that possible.

That’s why I see the planned self-driving, self-parking car as a life-saver in more ways than one. It not only may save lives by avoiding collisions, it will keep older adults independent in their homes.

Obviously these things are going to be ludicrously expensive when they hit the market. But consider what a year in a life-care community costs: thousands of dollars a month. You can hire a lot of cleaning help and buy a lot of restaurant breakfasts and dinners for six or eight or ten grand a month. And you could realistically get there in a car that will chauffeur you to the restaurant while you kick back and read your Kindle. Even at sixty, seventy, maybe even eighty thousand dollars, a self-driving vehicle would save so much over assisted living that it would pay for itself within a couple of years.

And you might have a shot of living life and enjoying it for that couple of years.

This is one of the reasons I decided not to replace the aging Dog Chariot in 2015. Admittedly, it’s way down on the list of reasons…but it surely does register. The lightrail extension past our ’hood will go into service late this year or (more likely) next year. A station will be within walking or scooter-riding distance of my house, and the train will run down to the Ghetto Costco, passing a Sprouts, a Walgreen’s, and two other grocery stores, as well as to the upscale AJ’s market and to all the downtown entertainment venues.

If that strategy works — riding the lightrail to reach places that sell basic needs — it will extend the ancient car’s lifetime by a lot. Even before I retired, I only put about 10,000 miles/year on the tank. If some of those miles can be traveled on a train, then the 30,000 to 50,000 miles that Chuck thinks he can squeeze out of the Chariot translate not as three to five years but as maybe six to ten years.

By then, automakers may very well have functional self-driving vehicles to put on the road. 🙂

6 thoughts on “Siri, Drive Me to Independence, Please”

  1. Interesting thoughts…Just took a call from a gal who is looking for a place for her “Grand-Pop”. It seems even though he is 90 he is sharp and quite active. Anyway he is living in a “facility” in West Virginia and it is costing $4500 a month and the family think it’s a rip-off. They are playing with the idea of renting a place….and the family pitching in for his care…We’ll see how this pans out. Know of a couple of friends whose parents had a “tidy sum” of money “evaporate” while paying for fees and the costs of living in a facility. When the parents passed there was barely enough left to bury them. Gonna agree with your resistance to living out my last days in a place like this. My parents are split over the choice…My Dad would “rather sleep in a car”…then go to a nursing home…My Mom says “I’d go tomorrow”…but I think she’s just tired of the housework and cooking. She visualizes a nursing home like a “hotel stay”….Sadly or not so sadly… I don’t think they’ll get the opportunity because in this neck of the woods there is a “means test” and if you have no money/assets you need not apply. IMHO my folks are luckier than they realize… that their family lives close and pitches in on their care and upkeep on their home… As for a car, I for one can’t wait for the day when I don’t need a car … The expenses…insurance…gas….maintenance…tags….emissions tests…taxes…have taken all the fun out of car ownership.

    • The cost of those places is astronomical. I have long-term care insurance but at this time it would cover only about half. It’s no longer inflation-adjusted, and so within a few years it will no longer be worth the premiums.

      What you get for forking over your life savings seems to me to be pretty questionable. For what you’re paying, I think you could hire help to come in, at least until you reach the point where you can no longer walk around the house, bathe yourself, and feed yourself, at which point you’d be better off dead anyway.

      At one point I figured out that my father was paying as much for a three-room apartment as my ex and I were paying for a 3,000-square-foot house on a third of an acre of prime North Central real estate — in the ritziest in-town neighborhood in the Phoenix area. It’s true, he got two meals a day and twice-monthly cleaning service…but the food was awful. What would it cost to buy breakfast and dinner at a mid-range eatery every day? Not, I’ll bet, what they were paying.

      What they were getting, and in the end it seemed worth it, was de facto nursing home insurance. The institution had a nursing home attached to it, for which the inmates got first dibs. It was excellent, with truly caring nurses and care-givers who delivered very, very fine care. But by the time he got there, he was oblivious anyway…it probably wouldn’t have mattered much where he died.

      While Medicare wouldn’t have covered long-term care, it would have covered hospice care, which is exactly what he got once he hit the nursing facility. So again: was it necessary to pay so much money over ten years for that?

      Your folks are very lucky to have family members who are willing to shoulder their care…that’s for sure. But it’s a lot to ask, especially in our culture with its “take-care-of-yourself” ethic. Ours is not a society whose values foster adopting and caring for infirm adults.

      • Couple of things….First read over your LTC policy and see what it actually covers. As memory serves GE was big in this biz AND exited….no money to be made… And I seem to remember an article not so long ago that predicted that the insurance companies underwriting these policies would collapse under the weight of claims as our population ages. IMHO the whole “aging industry” is a bit of a rip off. My Dad not so long ago expressed an interest in getting “meals on wheels” delivered to give my Mom a break as he under goes treatment. He quickly changed his mind when he found out that he could eat at a very nice restaurant for what it would cost to have a meal delivered. And the meals are just awful. DW makes up a batch of his favorite soup and he’s set!!! Gives Mom a break and he loves the soup.”.My folks struggle WITH our help. I’m pretty sure DW and I “are up the creek” as our kids will have careers…family and responsibilities of their own….”it is what it is”….Pretty sure we won’t be alone…

  2. I’m a good deal younger and I would definitely consider buying the self-driving car, especially if Mr PoP weren’t around to do the bulk of the driving for me. I can’t help but think once a critical mass of these things get on the roads, the streets and sidewalks will be safer for everyone – those in cars, bicyclists, and pedestrians.

  3. I’m with you about a leap into the Grand Canyon when things get bad. I refuse to spend the twilight years in fear and loneliness. Maybe we’ll gather a group together and have a final meal of really great Mexican food, a pitcher of margaritas ……..and leap. 😀

  4. I’m getting depressed about my prospects once I reach decrepitude. I have no kids to take care of me. The LTC insurance I’m paying for may be worthless? Maybe I should just party down now and then hope for a quick end. 🙁

Comments are closed.